Why do I always do this to myself. I get served with another giant plate that I didn’t order. But for some reason, I do want to eat it. That’s how I feel about the Moorish Idol, and its daunting task of keeping it in an enclosed system. It is something that I am now fully engaged in, thanks to my reefing drive!
There are very few reefers that have been able to keep these glamorous fish for more than 2 years in captivity. A task that is not achievable, so far, by most intermediate reefers. But fear not folks, I will be determined to fully succeed.
First, I needed to make sure that it had enough swimming and personal space (320 gallons for one specimen.. check). As well, had to make sure that it was eating in the LFS’s holding tank (ate mysis without a problem.. check). Finally, provide enough nutrition for it to thrive for a long, long time (isn’t why I am doing this post?).
So what does it eat in the wild? Could I find its nutrition somewhere on a store shelf? Here is some research data showing the Zarclus cornutus’s (MI) strict diet in the wild: Full Chart Here
Diet % Food I Food II Food III Prey Stage 84.50 % zoobenthos sponges/tunicates sponges juv./adults 11.30 % plants other plants benthic algae/weeds n.a./others
(source FishBase.gr)
Almost 85% of its food diet revolves around sponges, 11% algae, and the rest are benthic inverts. So that poses a dilemma, how do you provide a specific sponge diet to this fish? I managed to supply the 11% of the algae intake, covered in the form of Veggie Flakes. But what about sponge?
Hikari, a leading manufacturer of frozen and flake food for the industry, has a product that contains a mixture of many essential ingredients for picky eaters (such as the MI, and angels), which includes sponges. Here is an excerpt from their website:
MEGA-MARINE™ ANGEL Is High In Freshwater Helping Your Fish Purge Salt From Their System & Digest The Food More Completely With Less Energy – Expect Faster Growth & More Vibrant Colors.
Sponge, sea algae, sea urchin, sea worms, ocean plankton, krill, shrimp, clam, mussel, squid, spirulina, algae extract, cod liver oil, vitamins and minerals.
But is that enough?
Since I already have a good population of green, white, red, yellow, and orange sponges growing within the rocks, I do not think that they can grow fast enough to provide the Zarclus cornutus the necessary self-sustaining food. So, what I am seriously considering, is to stock up the reef with as many sponges that I can find at the LFS. I haven’t seen a MI eat a sponge before so the rate of consumption is still unknown to me, but if I supplement the reef with enough sponge (with the regular feedings of the Hiakri Sponge Food, I can possibly sustain the levels of required nutrition for this amazing specimen.
Will update you all with how this is progressing as we move forward. Currently he is eating mysis (which he loves, but i fear gives him very little nutritional value), and HBH Veggie Flakes (again, he gulps these with the fastest eating fish). I have to train him to eat the Hikari, as he is not crazy about it yet.

excellent !!!!!
would love to follow your progress as i have passed over these beauties for many years now.
good luck
Steve
I will definitely keep you all up to date (as always). I have conquered keeping a healthy Copperband Butterfly (as seen above), so why not a Moorish Idol?
Good luck. Definitely a show piece. If you can get fresh live sponge that will help greatly.
Thats the idea. I will try to acquire as much of live sponge as I can. If it grows fast enough in the tank, it may sustain in for months. Then all I need to do is restock on the sponge. A tad expensive for a fish, but its the price you need to pay to house one of these beauties.
Make sure you check out this recent article on keeping Zanclus by Pedro Nuno Ferreira.
http://www.manhattanreefs.com/forum/reefs-magazine/52020-keeping-zanclus-cornutus-moorish-idol-spongivore-fishes.html
Thanks for the link Jake. Personally, I have already read this article a year ago, but for this post, it is very beneficial. It shows you what kind of work is required to keep one healthy.
Check out this long thread on RC: http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=607477&perpage=25&pagenumber=1
It’s my wife’s favorite fish that we may attempt. She read the entire thread and what she gleaned from the thread is that they are highly prone to infection and it isn’t necessarily what you feed them but how often. Be prepared to feed 4-5 times a day. A vast majority of the people who have kept them have fed a lot and often. Good Luck and keep us informed.
Thank you for the link Benjie. There is a lot to learn from this fish, as it is highly coveted in this hobby. Unfortunately, not many have succeeded in keeping them thriving.
So it’s been almost 2 years…and no followup posts. How did your Moorish Idol fare? I’m assuming it was a failure (because if it was a success I assume you’d be screaming about it at this point). So most likely, the most appropriate question is “what went wrong”? Please share so others can benefit from your experience, good or bad.
Hey Matt,
My MI ended up ripping its lower jaw into two pieces. So all it had was a half of a jaw. Therefore it couldn’t graze on anything that was in the tank. So its starved and died.
I might attempt another one, but not anytime soon.